on August 9th, 2012

Dear Colleagues

An interesting little (simple) brain teaser for you – no matter whether what discipline or type of engineering professional you are.

The Challenge
A tank at atmospheric pressure contains 1 kg of air. The tank is then pressurized with an additional 3 kgs of air. What is the resultant gauge pressure (in bars) in the tank after this 3kgs of air has been added? Absolute pressure = gauge pressure + atmospheric pressure

A. 1 bar
B. 3 bar
C. 4 bar

You could use the Universal Gas Law in your deliberations:

PV = nRT

Where V is volume; P is absolute pressure; n is the number of moles (‘molecules’); R is a constant and T is the temperature.

Assume atmospheric pressure is 1 bar (the initial pressure) – naturally this is a number which could change depending on what altitude you are at.

Solution (suggested – you could do it in a myriad of different ways)
There is initially 1kg of air occupying V0 initial volume.

With 3kgs of air added; there is now a total of 4kg of air in the tank (thus the final number of moles or particles is effectively 4 times that of the initial number).

The volume (V0) and temperature (TO) of the tank still stays the same.

Thus:

P0 V0  = n0 R T0 (initial state)
P1  V0  =  n1 R T0  (final state where n1 = 4 x n0)
Thus – dividing each side of equation 1 and 2 we get:

P1  V0 / P0 V0  =  4 x n0 R T0  /  n0 R T0

P1  V0 / P0 V0  =  4 x n0 R T0  /  n0 R T0

Thus P1 = 4 P0

Hence, the final pressure P1 = 4 bar absolute or 3 bar gauge pressure (thus answer B above)

Do you agree?

My humble appreciation to Dr Rodney Jacobs and David Spitzer (the flow guru) for their contributions and critique.

Albert Einstein remarked: I never teach my pupils. I only attempt to provide the conditions in which they can learn.

Yours in engineering learning

Steve


      

The latest news

Namibian EIT Graduate Shares How Our Professional Certificate Helped Him Stay Ahead of Change

Namibian EIT Graduate Shares How Our Professional Certificate Helped Him Stay Ahead of Change

Rhys Nakalundu Mbala, EIT graduate and owner of Trinitas, reflects on how earning the Professional Certificate of Competency in Hydrogen Energy – Production, Delivery, Storage, and Use has kept him...... Read more
EIT to Showcase Expertise at Africa Automation Technology Fair 2025

EIT to Showcase Expertise at Africa Automation Technology Fair 2025

EIT is excited to showcase its automation expertise at the Africa Automation Technology Fair (AATF) 2025! Join us in Johannesburg to explore how automation, AI, and digital transformation are shaping...... Read more
Mechanical Engineers: The Backbone of Autonomous Vehicle Innovation

Mechanical Engineers: The Backbone of Autonomous Vehicle Innovation

Autonomous vehicles are revolutionizing transportation, but their success hinges on mechanical engineers. From sensor integration to safety systems, discover how these experts shape the future of self-driving cars. Picture this:...... Read more
UK EIT | Engineering Institute of Technology